Eleven states to challange mandate in court

[Arkiehawg]

Health bill lawsuits are going nowhere - CNN.com


Opinion: Healthcare bill challenges DOA....

 

[Bob]

Attorneys general in 11 states poised to challenge healthcare bill / The Christian Science Monitor - CSMonitor.com

We knew this was coming. It'll be interesting to see what happens. I honestly don't know how the SC will interpret the mandate. The commerce clause has been used and abused many times, even by more conservative courts concerning marijuana legalization laws. Time will tell, we have a full four years to work toward a final ruling.

FYI - The state of Florida is one of the states launching a challenge.

not the state of florida, but this uber republican governor wannabee with a napoleon complex

 

[Lynnie]

GA is one of the states filing suit.

 

[poppy]

You see, this is just part of the problem that many do not understand and another reason why we need term limits. If you call a represenative or senator's office and express an opinion, it is ignored in many cases because you are not a "constituent". I am an American citizen and when they vote on ANY piece of legistation, it affects me. For them to ignore me because I don't live in and vote in their district and, yet, vote on an issue that affects everyone nationally, is to ignore the opinions of all, both constituents and other citizens calling to voice their opinions and concerns. Just another thing wrong with our system as it stands today. We no longer have national representative government, we have government of small individual districts...at least in the house.

They may not want to take your call but they think they know the opinions, this is why pollsters are multi-millionaires.

 

[GoodWitch58]

[

If states win their argument and the public mandate is deemed unconstitutional, then the Democrats will have a stronger argument for the public option or Medicare for all.

So when those states go ahead with their suits, then in a supremely ironic development, you might see the private insurance companies filing amicus briefs on behalf of the government to keep the public mandate alive.

I saw this in one of the comment forums I was reading...interesting. I would sure like to see the Republican Party put as much energy into offering up something positive, as they are putting into negative positions and action. Are there no conservative people who need health care improved?

 

[30ashopper]

[

I saw this in one of the comment forums I was reading...interesting. I would sure like to see the Republican Party put as much energy into offering up something positive, as they are putting into negative positions and action. Are there no conservative people who need health care improved?

It's only a challange to the national mandate, not the overall bill. I think this is a valid question to ask and should be brought to the SC for a ruling.

I wouldn't be surprised by the insurance industry siding with democrats, forcing million of healthy people onto their books is a great way to make lots of $$!

 

[Matt J]

You see, this is just part of the problem that many do not understand and another reason why we need term limits. If you call a represenative or senator's office and express an opinion, it is ignored in many cases because you are not a "constituent". I am an American citizen and when they vote on ANY piece of legistation, it affects me. For them to ignore me because I don't live in and vote in their district and, yet, vote on an issue that affects everyone nationally, is to ignore the opinions of all, both constituents and other citizens calling to voice their opinions and concerns. Just another thing wrong with our system as it stands today. We no longer have national representative government, we have government of small individual districts...at least in the house.

They are called representatives because they represent the interests of the people who live and vote in their allotted area. That's civics 101. :roll:

 

[Matt J]

Who has to show ID when spending cash? Where and when? I have never been asked, nor have I ever heard of this practice.

I have, I bought a car from a dealership for cash and had to show my ID. Anything over $10,000 requires proper ID and the IRS. It's to stop money laundering and organized crime.