Having lived there, I'd move to the Fairhope, area. I didn't have kids in school, but, I heard that West Mobile Semmes area, has a great school system.
It's beautiful and Ive heard only, great things! I know someone that lives there and loves it! They have a huge new retail development in the Spanish Fort area, just North of Daphne. I know of someone that's lived in that area for a long time and loves it. I would focus on Eastern bay area, personally. Eastern Shore Centre... experience the lifestyle.
I think Spanish Fort is more our speed. They have virtually no crime, plus their school system looks fabulous... they even have a fine arts program at the elementary school! We are taking a road trip New Years day to check it out, as well as Daphne and Fairhope. Thanks for the direction!
We have only visited the area, but Fairhope appears to be out of the movies, beautiful and the people are very friendly and welcoming. Best of luck on your move.
Love, Love, Love Daphne!!!! There is a place downtown....restaurant/saloon that has the BEST spider sandwiches!!!!! AND, they have a special treat for the ladies in the BR!