I think Nature Walk would be better off, financially speaking, trying to sell off the four residential lots upon which Seagrove Villas is built. Even if they took a hit, selling them at $2 Million each, they would have half of the note for that property paid for.
According to the Walton County Comp Plan, they will never be able to legally do what they say they have planned for that Beach Front property. Once the value of the buildings (not the lot) are diminished by 50% or more, for any reason, be it storm, fire, or tearing it down with a track hoe, the property will revert back to residential zoning. There is no way they can tear down those buildings as planned and rebuild new buildings, according to the Comp Plan. It is simply not allowed. However, if they do ditch the plans for the beach club, and they buildout and sell all of the homes in there, the owners and guests won't have a decent public beach access, where they can park and use the restrooms. A few could drive down to Bramble Grove access, but it is usually busy in the summer, and there are more potential users for it, closer to that area, when lots get built out. I really think they didn't do their homework when considering the Seagrove Villas property, or either they received terrible advice from someone. If they hadn't spent $16 Million, on that property, they would be better off financially, and still might be able to sell some lots and or homes. Hindsight is 20:20. Buying that beach property, they increased their cost basis for the land by more than $30,000 per lot, which probably doubled the basis.