Well, we are progressing. Last night I decided to put his crate (that he hates) beside the bed with the top open. This would keep him confined but I could still reach down and pet him when he started whinning... wait no WALING :shock: about being in the create. It worked! He finally calmed down. 1:30 he spoke up, so I took him outside and he did his bitness. Took him back to the crate and his protest was way less. Of course I'm feeding him praise and treats the whole time. He spoke up again at 6AM when I usually get up and all was good.