My friend wants to rent a place on either one and we wants to know which has better fishing. I've fished in eastern but it was a long time ago and I never tried Redfish lake so I didn't know what to tell him.
I'm guessing you are talking about Big Redfish Lake, rather than Little Redfish Lake. I think you will find more fish to catch in Eastern Lake than either of the Redfish Lakes. Head to the north side of 30A towards the northern end of the Lake to look for the big ones.
smiling joe is right about eastern lake only this time of year youll catch them closer to the beach side. of all lakes on 30a and ive fished them a ton, western lake on the south side of 30a is the best. artificial bait early morning and live bait the rest of the day. and remember, limit your kill